A Critical View of the Evaluation the Documents of Some Famous Hadiths

Sayyid Hatam Shukr

In the previous issue of the journal of Ulum-i Hadith, an article, entitled: Evaluating the Documents of Some Famous Hadith was published in which the author had doubted their authoritativeness and regarded them as unreliable. Utilizing the different views of the great scholars, the writer of this review holds that we cannot reject a hadith merely because it does not exist in hadith books. If the content of another hadith is the same as the former we can regard it as reliable and authentic.

Key Words: Ulum-i Hadith, Article, Evaluating the Documents of Some Famous Hadith.

Click Here to read the Original Paper