A Comparative Study of Al-Liali of al-Suyuti and Al-Mawduat of Ibn al-Jawzi on a Critique of the Hadiths on the Virtues of Imam Ali
There are some books, written by great hadith transmitters, on recognition of forged hadiths current among the Sunnite ulema. Two of such works are Al-Mawduat of Ibn al-Jawzi and Al-Liali al-Masnua fi’l-Ahadith al-Mawdua of al-Suyuti. The writer first defines the forged hadith, points out to the necessity of recognizing such hadiths, and then gives a list of the most famous books of Al-Mawduat. The writer’s main point of comparison centers on al-Suyuti’s and Ibn al-Jawzi’s introduction to their chapters on the forged hadiths on the virtues of Imam Ali. They both critically studied a number of hadiths concerning (1) Imam Ali’s admission of Islam prior to all other people. (2)
Key Words: Imam Ali, Virtues, Al-Mawduat, Ibn al-Jawzi and Al-Liali al-Masnua fi’l-Ahadith al-Mawdua of al-Suyuti
Click Here to read the Original Paper